Celebrating “Are You Building Links Or Building A Business?” 12 Years Later (A Hamsterdam History Lesson)
By Ethan Lazuk
Last updated:

Welcome to another edition of Hamsterdam History!
This is a series of posts where we look at “vintage” SEO articles to celebrate their contributors, gain historical knowledge, and discuss how things have changed (or haven’t) since.
In this edition, we’ll be looking at “Are You Building Links Or Building A Business?” by Casie Gillette for Search Engine Land on April 16, 2014.

Frankly, this article is fairly timeless. While I usually like to opine on how developments in search technology (like generative AI) have changed how we view historical articles, this one has some prescient takeaways.
Below I’ll include some excerpts from the article, then we’ll review takeaways in the context of today.
First we’ll start with the introductory section:
“… there is a problem happening around links at the moment that they aren’t exactly sure how to deal with — and the result is unwarranted penalties, miscommunication, and increased frustration from search marketers and marketers in general.
So what can we do?
The short answer is to focus on the business. For our clients, we are creating content intended to drive qualified traffic and leads, along with content intended to drive shares. We are helping clients build up their social presence and making sure they are participating in communities where their target audience is.
We are monitoring press mentions, helping them with third-party posts (aka guest posts), and identifying locations where a link will add real business value. None of what we are doing is building links for the sake of building links.”
Next is a section titled “Be A Brand”:
“… how do you become one of these infallible businesses? Focus on getting people talking about you in places that matter. You must have company reviews, social proof and mentions in authoritative publications. These things take work, but they are certainly attainable.”
The following section is perhaps my favorite. It’s titled “Diversify”:
“… one thing we have always said, and that still applies today, is this: don’t put all of your eggs in the Google basket.
One reason for this is that Google is doing everything it can to keep people on Google. …
We can no longer assume someone will get to the search result and click into our site, regardless of where we are ranked on the page. You must be able to be found elsewhere.
The great news is that there are other places to be found. Social networks have billions of users and are continuing to grow. People are searching on social, they are interacting with brands, they are sharing content, they are making recommendations to friends, and they are using it for business. …
The second, and most obvious reason for diversifying is this: if Google decided to penalize your site and remove you from the results, could your business survive? If the answer is no, then it’s time to start thinking about how you can diversify your efforts and get started. While this likely isn’t going to happen to you, it’s always smart to mitigate risk.”
The final section is titled “Don’t Freak Out”:
“… we don’t do anything for the sole purpose of just gaining a link. Our goal is to generate overall value to the business. If that means submitting our client to a directory, we are going to do that. Why? Because many of our clients are in manufacturing, where directories still play a role in how businesses find and contact one another.
What else? Well…
- If we stopped guest posting just because we heard guest posting was bad, I wouldn’t be writing this post.
- If we stopped issuing press releases, we wouldn’t have gotten multiple inquiries and pickups for a report we released last month.
- If we stopped participating in forums, my client would have had ~25 less leads last year.
- If we made sure to avoid reciprocal links, our clients and their distributors wouldn’t be able to link to one another — when trying to learn about products, that isn’t very helpful.
Anyway, I think you get the picture. The point is to focus on things that help the business. If that means doing something you heard doesn’t work, that’s okay. It may not work in gaining search visibility, but if it drives relevant traffic and potential leads, that’s what matters.
At the end of the day, we can’t constantly be worried about which links are good and which are bad. Instead, we can focus on doing things that will help the business in the long term.”
My Takeaways
What struck me when reading Casie’s 2014 article is how the same mistakes SEOs were making with links in 2014 are arguably being repeated with AI visibility tactics in 2026.
Casie’s original argument was essentially that links should be a byproduct of building a successful business, not the ultimate objective. Today, we could make the same argument about backlinks, brand mentions, AI citations, share of voice, and even organic traffic.
In short, the question is are we building visibility in search engines and LLMs, or are we building businesses that people actually want to discover, trust, and engage with?
It’s easy to get sidetracked my tactics and metrics and lose site of our ultimate goal: to help the businesses we work with succeed.
Here are some additional takeaways I had, tying the 2014 article to SEO/GEO today:
1. AI citations are like the new backlinks.
In 2014, SEO’s could become so focused on acquiring backlinks that they sometimes lost sight of why links mattered in the first place. We see a similar fascination with getting brands mentioned or cited in ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Perplexity, and other AI assistants today.
Consider the parallels:
- Then: How many backlinks did we acquire?
- Now: How many times did an LLM cite our website?
- Then: What’s the authority of the linking domain?
- Now: Which sources and platforms mention our brand?
- Then: Can we manipulate rankings through links?
- Now: Can we influence AI recommendations through brand mentions and third-party content?
In short, we shouldn’t pursue AI citations for the sake of citations. Rather, our focus should be on gaining visibility that improves awareness, consideration, trust, and ultimately business outcomes.
2. Brand building may be more important than ever, but not because of an algorithmic shortcut.
Brands today may be discovered, researched, compared, and recommended through AI-generated answers rather than through traditional search listings alone. That creates a reason to invest in authentic third-party coverage, customer reviews, expert commentary, and original research.
We shouldn’t confuse manufacturing signals of brand authority with earning genuine recognition and trust. A brand’s reputation always exists outside of the search engines or AI assistants that surface it.
3. The case for diversification has become even stronger.
While back in 2014 the concern was that Google could keep users on its own properties or change how websites appeared in search results, today, AI-generated answers introduce another layer between information discovery and a potential website visit.
The question becomes what happens when a business depends on a platform that controls not just which sources are shown, but also how their information is summarized and presented? That raises additional questions about how brands can maintain relationships with customers outside of search or AI platforms.
That’s why we should build owned audiences, email subscriptions, direct traffic, customer communities, and relationships that don’t depend entirely on an intermediary recommending our websites.
4. Build something worth retrieving, not just something optimized to be retrieved.
This is specific to the AI search era of today, where marketers are increasingly concerned with making content retrievable, extractable, and suitable for citation. But what if the underlying information offers nothing distinctive?
Original research, real expertise, proprietary data, and first-hand experiences can provide value to an audience whether they are discovered through Google, referenced by an AI assistant, or shared directly between people.
So while technical accessibility helps content get discovered, its originality that gives people a reason to care about discovering it.
5. Measure business impact rather than optimizing exclusively for platform metrics.
As SEO professionals, we traditionally measured rankings, impressions, clicks, backlinks, and organic traffic. GEO adds metrics such as brand mentions, citation frequency, citation share, and recommendation visibility. All of these can provide useful information, but none independently establishes that a business is succeeding.
Thus, we should treat search and AI visibility metrics as diagnostic indicators, not substitutes for measuring audience growth, qualified leads, conversions, customer relationships, and revenue.
Outro
In 2014, the question was whether we were building links or building businesses. Today, we could similarly ask the same question, just replacing links with building AI citations.
While the tools, interfaces, and opportunities for organic visibility have changed considerably in the last 12 years, perhaps the most timeless lesson from the 2014 article is that successful marketing isn’t about collecting signals that algorithms might reward. It’s about creating a brand worth discovering, discussing, recommending, and ultimately doing business with.
Backlinks are great, as are mentions in authoritative publications or recommendations by AI assistants, but those are just outcomes of a broader strategy, not necessarily the strategy itself.
I hope you’ve enjoyed this edition of Hamsterdam History!
Stay tuned for another edition soon, or check out related history articles below.
Until next time, enjoy the vibes:
Thanks for reading. Happy optimizing!
Related history posts:
The Enduring Importance of Micro-Moments (A Hamsterdam History Lesson)
The Enduring Importance of Micro-Moments (A Hamsterdam History Lesson) By Ethan Lazuk Last updated: Welcome to another edition of Hamsterdam History! This is a series…
Entities Talked About in 2010 and What Still Applies Today (A Hamsterdam History Lesson)
Entities Talked About in 2010 and What Still Applies Today (A Hamsterdam History Lesson) By Ethan Lazuk Last updated: Welcome to another edition of Hamsterdam…
Does Blog Content Still Influence Consumer Buying Behavior? Revisiting a 2008 Research Article (A Hamsterdam History Lesson)
Does Blog Content Still Influence Consumer Buying Behavior? Revisiting a 2008 Research Article (A Hamsterdam History Lesson) By Ethan Lazuk Last updated: Welcome to another…
Leave a Reply