Reactive vs. Proactive SEO/GEO Strategies. Why We Need Both (IMO)

The yin and yang of reactive vs. proactive SEO/GEO strategies.

I was having a conversation with an SEO agency owner and he raised a great point. To paraphrase: “So much of SEO/GEO today is reactive work, identifying sources of AI-generated answers and trying to influence them. What can we do that’s more proactive?”

My response was: “Focus on the business goals. If you’re achieving visibility with your target audience, you have to have faith that AI assistants and search algorithms will catch up to that and reward it with organic visibility in your niche.”

The problem with what I said, though, is that this strategy is partly exploratory and experimental … it’s like identifying Reddit threads influencing AI conversations, then finding similar new threads to contribute to, with the hope that they, too, will become sources of mentions.

Right after I had this conversation, I also saw this tweet by Bryan Casey:

It made me rethink the equation: we need to be both reactive and proactive as SEO/GEO professionals.

We need to react to where the models are getting their sources today while also focusing on future areas of influence, both for parametric knowledge as well as RAG retrievals.

The exact balance of where to focus attention likely depends on how niche and durable the sources for target topics/prompt categories tend to be. For example, a low degree of durability likely means that a future-focus is preferable, whereas a higher durability likely means that focusing on today’s sources will also yield results down the road. Of course, even that is debatable (high source volatility, for example, could imply that both reactive and proactive strategies are needed).

Nonetheless, I still think it comes down to the business case: where are the sources of information our audience uses today (and in the future) and how can we become a prominent part of that conversation?

You can even extend that way of thinking to AI models themselves: which models does our audience use most today, and which models are they likely to use in the future? Then focus on the sources contributing to visibility in those models and invest in both current and likely future sources.

A BIG part of the equation here is also client education and trust. Since focusing on likely future-sources of influence is exploratory work, the client will need to understand the value inherent to the strategy. Again, though, it comes back to business case: even if the third-parties you’re getting mentioned in never become sources for AI answers, they still likely got your brand in front of your target audience during their buyer’s journey. And isn’t that the ultimate goal?

All that’s to say, take a look at your current SEO/GEO strategy. How much of it is reactive and how much is proactive? The right balance depends on each brand’s unique situation, but having a balance is essential.

This balance also creates a feedback loop: reactive data collection can inform proactive decisions, while proactive investments can create new opportunities to evaluate through reactive monitoring.

Some examples:

  • Reactive: Identify websites cited in AI answers.
  • Proactive: Build relationships with relevant publishers and communities.
  • Reactive: Analyze competitors’ AI mentions.
  • Proactive: Develop original research worth referencing.
  • Reactive: Address gaps in current AI visibility.
  • Proactive: Establish expertise in emerging topics.

Takeaway:

A reactive SEO/GEO strategy tells us where visibility comes from today, while a proactive approach helps us create the conditions for visibility in the future. The best strategies use both, all the while ensuring every investment delivers business value regardless.

If you want guidance with your SEO/GEO strategies, feel free to contact me. I’m an independent consultant in NYC helping brands and agencies globally.

Until next time, enjoy the vibes:

Thanks for reading. Happy optimizing!

Related posts

Editorial history:

Created by Ethan Lazuk on:

Last updated:

Need a hand with your SEO/GEO strategy?

I’m an independent SEO/GEO consultant based in New York City. Contact me for more information!

Leave a Reply